[Only Topic]Who do you like better? Cloney Syaoran or R|Syaoran?

No, it sounds good. I think we all have theories on how cloney could die. I have heaps.

Hahaha, I have heaps too, but this one was the only one that I like and makes somewhat sense with these recent chapters. I can't imagine Syaoran and Sakura having an unhappy ending, even after all they've gone through. The ending in CCS is still stuck in my head, and just seeing that fluffy ending is enough evidence for me to think that CLAMP love Syaoran and Sakura enough not to make them suffer TOO much (since they've suffered a lot starting from Acid!Tokyo ) I try not to kill myself with all of the ideas and plots swarming my mind, though. It might not be good for my mind when I see more theories in this forum, but I love it anyways, because this is the only place I can discuss and theorize with fellow fans

Guys, this is getting out of control! The "ending" dissussion/prediction should be discussed in another section like>>What do you think will happen at the end of TRC? Please, please, please stick to the usual topic. Anyone who is continue posting spam or unrelated messages and do not follow the Admins requests will get their points deducted or a sign of warnings.

Oh, I'm so sorry! I'll try not to do it again! I sometimes have problems with going off-topic...

So, guys, C!Syaoran or R!Syaoran? I prefer R!Syaoran, personally, but I want to hear why you also like R!Syaoran or would prefer C!Syaoran. The score is 6-5 in favor of C!Syaoran. Let's get R!Syaoran up! *waves flag*

Well. like I have mentioned before, I personally like C|Syaoran before he initially became evil. I still like him though, because he is still the Syaoran that I have always been obsessing with from the start till now. Thus his personality has changed due to the fact that he was manipulated by Butt Chin but he is still Clow/Cloney Syaoran for me.

CLoney Rules, hooray . Nothing will change my mind about Cloney ( and I do believe that he has a heart and soul of his own, even he is simply just an artificial being), and is not I dislike R|Syaoran, I truly love both of them R|Syaoran and Cloney but Cloney wins my heart more. I know a lot of people prefer the Real Syaoran cos he is the orginal one but for me, I don't care if Cloney isn't the original~ he is my original so he's the orignal T_______T

Cloney! He's wicked cool!XD

woop! another Cloney fan! hooray

(I thought I replied to this topic...hmm...)

Anyway, I will always be a Cloney fan. He was the first Syaoran I came to know, and I felt that his story was so sad in that he could save Sakura, but she would never have those memories with him...it used to make me emo reading that scene in Outo where she passed out on him after asking him that question...

And even though Cloney's evil now, I believe in him. He has to have his own heart and memories in there somewhere. I know R!Syaoran's had a sad past, but...I dunno, Cloney just strikes me as more of a tragic story as opposed to the real one.

Yay! Someone agrees iwth me exactly!! Seriously, I think nearly the exact same things. I don't know why, but I always imagine just sayiong this: yeah, there were hard times, but you lived your life. ALL of it. While he just got to live from seven years old. And the first emotion he ever felt was pain (that part always makes me depressed) while the original knew his home, knew who his parents were, and actually knew his own name!

Cloney woop! Cloney does have a heart but we're not sure if his heart has yet activated or not, well, after his Sakura died, he was literally screaming out for her so there could be a sign there . Still even Cloney is evil, he is always our number one Syaoran from the start till now.

I agree with you completely, Chibi-san. Cloney has to have a heart.. and to me, he'll alwqys be my number one!

Differences between cloney and "SYaoran"
firts: Cloney is actually Syaoran, called that by Fujitaka.
2nd: Cloney thinks with hsi heart. "Syaoran" thinks things through ,kind of
3rd: Cloney had such a hard first part of his chlildhood! (Honestly, not remembering his name, his family, where he was, getting stared at like he was a monster)
4th: Cloney is younger then he looks, "Syaoran" is older then he looks
5th: Cloney doesn' have a choice here!
6th: Cloney forced to do FWR's bidding
7th: if Cloney remembers what he did to Fai, I bet you he'd be really upset
8th: if Cloney remembers all teh worlds he destroyed, he would be beside himself

and there's more but that's all I can think of right now. Sorry if this list upset anybody......

Subaru-kun wrote:
8th: if Cloney remembers all teh worlds he destroyed, he would be beside himself

I don't think he needs to remember all the worlds he destroyed to do that. :grin:

I just like all Syaorans XD but with these two, I really can't choose! I like them both for different reasons. But I tend to draw cloney more, because for some reason I like drawing one blue eye and one brown eye - it just looks awesome to me XD

i love them both, but i guess i feel for C!Syaoran more ..

his story is just too trgic IMO, and everytime i read the earlier manga chapters i feel my heart break, he was always so sweet ...

and i really really hope everything will end well for him .. one of my wishes for the next chapters is to have Fay/Kurogane/Mokona remember him as he was, a nakama not just a clone, and actually be sad about the turn of events because i dont think we saw that..

I agree. I think that the others just...... practically forgot! They just think: evil, this Syaoran is teh one we knew....

I just love both of them, but I think it'd be Clone!Syaoran because of all those beautiful times with him and the Tsubasa group.

I guess majority of you guys are all Clone Syaoran fans^^;. Apart from me, I loved them both and I actually had a hard time dealing with two Syaorans!!! But then again I figured that Clone Syaoran and real Syaoran are almost similar . Real Syaoran gave the clone half of his heart, so it is the essence of the same person. The only difference was that they were living different experiences.

IceQueen wrote:I guess majority of you guys are all Clone Syaoran fans^^;. Apart from me, I loved them both and I actually had a hard time dealing with two Syaorans!!! But then again I figured that Clone Syaoran and real Syaoran are almost similar . Real Syaoran gave the clone half of his heart, so it is the essence of the same person. The only difference was that they were living different experiences.

Yay, IceQueen-san! I agree with you on that completely! It's been literally impossible for me to choose between Clone!Syaoran and Real!Syaoran, simply because their personalities are so much alike that there's no use in trying to determine the difference, in my opinion. I feel sorry for R!Syaoran with all the votes Cloney's getting xD Lol, even if you were basing your preference on the Horitsuba Syaorans, where I believe Syaoran is based off of C!Syaoran and Syaoron is based off of R!Syaoran, it'd still be hard for me to choose because I simply adore Syaoron/R!Syaoran and....yeah. It's hard to choose Can't we just have them all? *huggles all the Syaorans* xD

Isn't it natural, however, for more people to choose Clone Syaoran? Like I stated once before; he was naturally the hero for quite a long time, and essentially, we were lead to believe it was his story. The story of a brave hero, who desperately desired to save his beloved regardless of the painful price(s) he had to pay.

But to say he was like "Syaoran", I cannot believe. Cloney was very rash in his desperate decision to save Sakura. He was very shy, polite, and quite modest. He did not hide his feelings, and had a difficult time hiding pain or sorrow. He constantly (and without thinking) placed himself in harm's way if he thought Sakura or his friends were in danger. He hardly considered himself; which is both good or bad. He hardly put much thought into things, and when he did, it was quite narrow-minded, based on what the decision would do for his Sakura. He also was a little gullible.

But "Syaoran" is very different. He THINKS quite rashly about all situations; and he can hide is pain quite well. It's most likely because he's lived two lives, Cloney's and his original. He went through quite a lot, while Cloney's lived a rather tamed and happy life.

They both had quite different personalities; but they also lived quite different experiences. Aside from "Syaoran" surrendering some of his heart to Cloney, Cloney's experiences and how his "heart" grew were based on Cloney's lifestyle, with (from my understanding) little influence on "Syaoran's" part, disregarding the anxiety he had from turning back time.

I prefer Cloney because I favoured Cloney's differences between him and his CCS||Counter-part, but also his similarities. CCS||Syaoran was very thoughtful and intelligent, but if Sakura were in trouble, he'd be a little rash, too. However, Cloney was quite polite and modest, and CCS||Syaoran was far from so. Although CCS||Syaoran cared deeply for his friends and family, he put on a rude, even somewhat hostile mask.

Cloney's constant caring for Sakura, and his kindness (although sometimes he appeared disgusting kind, if that were even possible) strongly appeal to me. "Syaoran" feels more like a villian (I know he's not.) He replaced our (originally) pleasant and polite Cloney - and the entire story changed drastically upon his arrival. Although I do like "Syaoran", and feel for him - I simply cannot give up the attachment I felt to his Clone, the more readable of the two.

I love both of them really. They both are good and bad in their own ways. But if I had to pick, it'd be R|Syaoran. Sorry to the Cloney Syaoran fans.

Invisible_Writer wrote:Can't we just have them all? *huggles all the Syaorans* xD

I like this idea

:3

*huggles*

I like Cloney better. I don't know why- but I just like him better...He was so cute before Tokyo!! Maybe it's also because he was there with the other since the beginning, and now that he got back his 'soul' or 'heart' or whatever, he seemed to have sacrificed himself. D:

Cloney X3 He's awesome! I love every bits about Cloney not matter if he's evil or not x3